Email Marketing Tip: Ignore Replies at Your Own Peril

Email

Part of the standard marketing playbook that (I hope) everyone uses are timely and relevant updates and annoucements to your customer/subscriber base via email.  There are a variety of dead simple tools out there that do this like VerticalResponse, Constant Contact, MailChimp, and ExactTarget that all have different levels of sophistication but essentially do the same thing:

  1. Provide an editor to create email content (text, html, etc.)
  2. Proivide a list manager to upload and organize email addresses
  3. Provide reporting to see opens, clicks, bounces, unsubscribes, etc.

The wide availability of these types of solutions means pretty much anyone can use one if they have something to say and a list of opt-in email addresses (i.e, no spamming).  I am a firm believer in respecting the inbox of your recipient and delivering meaningful, relevant information where unsubscribing is easy so don't abuse the priviledge of being able to send someone an email – it can be revoked quickly…and completely.

One of the things I most look forward to after sending out an email update are the responses.  I have learned many things over the years including things I didn't want to find out like like broken links, formatting problems, and mis-spelling to important things like customer issues and even compliments and praise.

I am continually surprised when email updates arrive in my inbox and no one is paying attention to the responses.  If you send me an email, don't you at least consider the fact I may respond? Worse yet, why would you not monitor the replies…and tell me that?

Try responding to the next one you receive with a question or observation and see if you get a response.

Stop being so concerned about yourself, your open rates, your click rates, etc. and focus on the person to whom you are sending the email.  Just because you are sending many at one time does not mean that they all won't be received and acted upon individually.

Set aside the time to respond personally and you'll be amazed at what you learn.

What are good email marketing open and click rates?

I'm a fan of using email marketing as part of a broader marketing plan as long as it is not abused and functions as a platform to share information the recipient will find valuable as opposed to shameless product pitches. 

There are lots of different options here including self-service ones like VerticalResponse (which I currently use), Constant Contact, and MailChimp as well as ones like Portland-based eROI and Nashville, TN-based Emma which integrate agency services along with the email capability.  The full list of options is very long (including Atlanta-based Silverpop & Seattle neighbor WhatCounts) and I know I am not doing it justice here.

The purpose of this post is to dig into what are good results from an email marketing campaign.  How many opens, clicks, bounces, unsubscribes, etc. are actually good when compared to what is best in class?

I know what I have seen in my efforts and am happy to discuss one-on-one if you are interested.  Here is what I found after a few quick searches:

  • Great chart from the folks at MailChimp with a breakdown by industry (small businesses).  The average of the averages (sorry mathematicians) pegs this around a 25% open rate with just over a 4% click rate looking across some 273M sent emails. Unsubscribes are pretty low at .36% while hard bounces (not a valid email) seem high to me at almost 6%.  People change jobs and email addresses go stale but I have not seen a result this high or it could be due an extended interval between sends.

  • Good stats posted on eMarketer although pegging the high end of list size at 1000+ seems curious to me (my lists are always much larger than this and I hope yours are too)Their citation of a report by MailerMailer puts the "worldwide" open rate at 12.5% at the end of 2008.

I'm not sure I am leaving you with what is best in class but at least this can function as a frame of reference.  I am not an email marketing expert by any means but believe in it and its responsible use for any organization.

Earn permission to respond

This is a great (and short) blog post by Seth Godin on the topic of being accessible and making it easy for people to initially contact you.  Think about the last time you wanted information or were looking to buy something.  Did you want to answer a bunch of questions or provide a lot of information about yourself?

Email contact is like a first date. If you show up with a clipboard and
a questionnaire, it's not going to go well, I'm afraid. The object is
to earn permission to respond.

Keep it simple.  Request an email address or make it easy for people to send you an email with some questions (and be sure to respond quickly!).  This is just the beginning of the discussion not the end.