Not that this question ranks up there with the greatest of all time, but it did come up recently in a conversation and thought it was worth sharing.
Regardless of whether technically you could lose one and not the other is not the issue here rather which do you put more value on? If your inbox was taken away, would your world come to a halt?
I suppose this is dependent on what you do and how you manage your information. If you are like most people, your email is your central file repository, contact manager, and #1 business application used during the day. Here’s how I see it:
1. Inbox – information sent to you and/or many others
* No control over who sends you what (other than spam/virus filters)
* Some control upon receipt by automated or manual folders (managed folders approach)
* Includes informational or no action types of messages where you are one of many, a distribution list member, or CC/BCC
* Receiving something (i.e., successful delivery) is not the same as accepting it, agreeing with it, or implying you will act on it
* Greater propensity to reply to an important messages thereby putting a copy of it in the Sent Folder
2. Sent Folder – information you share with identified recipients
* You send fewer emails than you receive and this requires deliberate action
* Creates a personal audit trail to “prove” that you did something and when
* Contains your original or modified work product (including ability to find the most recent one)
* Identifies your most important contacts or at least those that you interact with more frequently
For me, I would choose the Inbox to live without. Maybe this is a function of how I work and spend my day – right or wrong. Whether you could live without both is another post.